File this one under "yet another blog post about separating the artist from the art or something". Just a wee rant/random thought. Skip if you don't give a shit about that stuff.
"Never meet your heroes" is an adage filled with dread and tension. We all have folks who we idolize in some way or another to lesser or greater degrees. If you love movies by Hitchcock, then you are a Hitchcock fan even if you don't like being saddled with that term. And yet Hitchcock wasn't a perfect man (I actually don't know much about him, so maybe he was terrible... I don't know, it's not the point).
In my youth I was influenced by a lot of artists and I still fondly remember their work. I do a Sunday blog post each week called Artists I Like and I highlight someone whose work inspires me. If I know an artist is a piece of shit or has some seriously controversial opinion, I might choose to avoid talking about them for that reason. I have no interest in expanding the lore of an asshole. But also, I have almost no interest in defending an asshole whose only connection to me is they drew a picture I love.
Anyway... I had Armando Gil on my list. Gil was a comics artist for Marvel, DC, etc. I know him pretty much only from the Savage Sword of Conan pinups he drew, which were incredible. So different from other artists' work, so rich and vibrant
I was working up a post about Gil so I looked him up to get a general idea about him. Turns out he was convicted of multiple counts of rape in 2017 and is now in prison.
The fact that I loved his Conan art and that it influenced me as a teen cannot ever be changed. And I'll never say I DON'T love his work. But it is also my choice to promote or not promote someone based on my own feelings about them. I have no desire to promote a convicted rapist, so I won't be including this guy in my Sunday post series.
Normally this is because I don't want to contribute to someone like this financially or socially. In this case I don't think there's much benefit to Gil for anyone talking about him. That ship has sailed. He's never going to be back in the saddle. But aside from that, I have my own principles and endorsing someone like that is not on my list of things to do.
There have been a few other artists who were slated to be on the Sunday list who I removed for similar reasons. Not quite as extreme as this one, but uncomfortable enough that I didn't want to talk about them. Also, I probably already talked about someone who you think was or is a bastard. I didn't do extensive research on all of them. And I don't care about trivial infractions. So what if this or that artist once told someone to fuck off at a convention. Even a dickhead can be good at drawing.
It's my choice. I know that some people are of the opinion that none of this matters and that you should talk about whatever artist you want to talk about, regardless of their deeds. I agree. And I don't want to talk about this one anymore.
The Artists I Like series is about expressing my admiration for work that inspires me. I'm sure 99% of the artists I talk about are wonderful people. Some of them might be assholes. I can live with a few assholes slipping through the gate. And, to be totally transparent, if I post one and later find out something about them that I can't tolerate, I'll just remove that post. That is me doing what I want, on my own.
I think this is all very, very reasonable. I get really frustrated by the assertion that we're somehow giving in to an oppressive culture that just wants to cancel everyone, if we just don't want to talk up folks we know are assholes. Especially with art...the things we love are really hard to separate from the creator, which is part of what makes it art in the first place, as opposed to some algorithm-based product made for maximum sensory appeal.
ReplyDeleteYes. And for me, what I wanted to get across in this post was that it's MY CHOICE. The ones you speak of who blame "cancel culture" are the first ones to scream about free speech. But they only seem to be screaming when they get criticized for promoting a shitty person or idea. Just because you CAN give currency to an asshole doesn't mean you SHOULD. That's the point. I can talk about Armando Gil if I god damn well want to. But I DON'T WANT TO. Because he's a convicted rapist. Why in the FUCK would I want to give him positive attention? It's not cancel culture driving this decision, it's my making my own damn choices. /rant
DeleteHaha...a worthwhile rant, my guy. You actually hit on some specific stuff that I was thinking while responding...I just hold back a bit when I'm not sure of the temperature so as not to stir up shit for no reason.
DeleteYou nailed it and covered one of my greatest struggles with getting along happily in the current America...the celebration of assholery under the guise of celebrating individuality.
The story that really opened my eyes on this front: I'm from Georgia, and when there was a "Chick-Fil-A Day" to support the company after its founder made some homophobic statements, it was HUGE. Like people I never would have guessed would support it were like, "yeah, be American and buy Chick-Fil-A!" It was weird.
The "excuse" that I kept seeing was, "no, no, I'm not homophobic, I just support free speech!" Okay. Maybe so. Benefit of the doubt, I guess.
And then Colin Kaepernick started kneeling, and I looked for all of those same people to support free speech...
(Thanks for indulging me. No worries if you didn't want to read all that... ;)